This is simply not a good title for an article. It's completely uninformative and non-descriptive. I'm not even totally convinced that the information here merits its own article. It would seem to be better suited as part of the Ikoma family or Emperor of Rokugan articles. ~ShibaRyu~
20:46, 23 May 2007 (UTC)
Way of the Scorpion page 30, second column. A subsection called "To Protect the Emperor..."
As I'm adding the Way of the Scorpion to the site, under the book project, I thought it sensible to include this subsection as it's in the book and is a fairly big part of what the Scorpion do as a clan, within the empire.
As it involves the Scorpion and Lion, putting it merely in one clan/family's section seemed wrong thus I created it as it's own article with the Scorpion and Lion as the categories.
As for the title, it's what the game writers used, so seemed good enough to me.
The Way of the Scorpion page has a link to it, thus it's not as if it's not referenced anywhere. If you want, I'll add links to it from the Ikoma's and Shosuro's pages?
SamuraiRaccoon 07:50 24th May 07 (GMT)
- I'm not saying it doesn't belong in the Wiki; I'm just saying I'm not sure it belongs on its own page. And the title, even if it is a section heading from an RPG book, is simply too flowery to be a decent title for an encyclopedia article. I'm open to arguments that the content here merits its own article, but the title has to change to something useful. ~ShibaRyu~
13:59, 24 May 2007 (UTC)
- How about something like: Shosuro/Ikoma Alliance. Then put links into it from the family pages, while keeping the link in the Way of the Scorpion page as the subsection title from the book? Would this be ok? SamuraiRaccoon 15:31 24th May (GMT)
Two years after...
- I think that as it stands, the article is fine. Nice work on adding more info btw. What we should do is add a paragraph on the Shosuro family and Ikoma family articles mentioning this alliance and pointing at this page. --Majushi 18:08, January 29, 2010 (UTC)
I have the same feeling as ShibaRyu. Why not "forgotten history" / "re-write history" / "awful truths" ? And so, the article will be more general, and include information from WoS -- Goshimo 21:59, January 28, 2010 (UTC)